"Everybody Stares: The Police Inside Out" is a first person account. Taken from over 50 hours of film shot by Copeland, Stewart gives his views and opinions of the phenomenon known as The Police in the early 1980s. The hour and 15 minute video shows what Stewart saw and lived. His view of the world as The Police began in London and reached stardom before they called it quits in 1984.

While many band videos are full of performances with an extra behind the scenes feature thrown in, "Everybody Stares: is nothing but behind the scenes footage with a short performance clip bonus feature thrown in at the end. But don't tune in looking for a film full of arguments and fights; while there should be a label warning of some very colourful expletives, there are no fights to be seen here. As Stewart put it in the film, "we laugh more than we shout."