||Live 8 DVD Special
by Jacob McDaniel
Click here to read the latest
installment in this special review series.
Twenty years after Live Aid was held to
benefit victims of the Ethiopian famine, Live 8 was organized to persuade
leaders of G8 to "make poverty history" - primarily by increasing financial
aid and AIDS medication, while canceling debts to some of the poorest African
countries. Past global concerts have been used as a fund-raising tool for
a cause. Live 8, however, claims that they only want your voice. Perhaps
I'm naïve, but I fail to see how collecting donations would have tarnished
their agenda. At any rate, an estimated three billion people watched some
part of the concert series, making it one of the biggest music events of
Disc one opens with a bang, as Paul McCartney
plays "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band" with the help of U2 backing
him. Although Paul is dressed fairly conservatively, someone decided that
his horn section should don the garb of the Beatles during that 1967 time
period. I'm hoping that they enjoyed wearing their flamboyant outfits as
much as I enjoyed snickering at them.
Next on the bill is U2 playing a three
song set ("Beautiful Day", "Vertigo", "One"). I've never cared for U2's
music, and I've cared even less for Bono's preachy humanitarian rants.
However, U2 was made to play events like this, and Bono's piercing voice
seemed to be one of the few that was there to make a difference. U2's set
climaxed and closed with "One", which was executed perfectly.
One of the few other highlights from disc
one came when Richard Ashcroft joined Coldplay on stage for a rendition
of "Bittersweet Symphony". Ashcroft's vocals were in top shape, and Martin's
keyboard work meshed nicely with the backing orchestration.
Great performances: U2, Coldplay
(w/ Richard Ashcroft), Green Day
Good performances: Muse, Black
Poor performances: Bon Jovi, Snoop
Dogg, Duran Duran, Elton John
Disc two opens with Beyonce-led Destiny's
Child pumping through "Survivor", which proved to be one of the more energetic
performances in this compilation. Kanye West also delivers with "Diamonds
from Sierra Leone", in which his confident aura shows in his stage presence.
Disc two also contains one of the most
sickening performances, an act that reveals the main problem of Live 8:
Are the artists performing in order to rid Africa of poverty, or are they
performing for access to billions of potential fans? Will Smith is carried
onto the stage on a throne, as the loudspeakers repeat the phrase, "The
champ is here". Smith then says, "There's been a whole lot of superstars
on this here stage tonight. But I want you to know one thing: Philly is
my house." It's a shame that such ego-stroking occurs during Live 8, and
it's even more of a shame that the artist most guilty has perhaps the most
suspect credentials. Perhaps the most appalling part of the situation is
that Will Smith is given three songs on disc two, while Kanye West, Brian
Wilson, and Snow Patrol are all given only one.
Great performances: Kanye West,
Good performances: Destiny's Child,
Snow Patrol, Alicia Keys, Sting
Poor performances: Will Smith,
Disc three is a real mystery. For some
reason, the organizers paired some of the worst performances with the best,
with the dichotomy split nearly down the middle. If it wasn't for Neil
Young, who (like many great artists who played at Live 8) was only allocated
one song, the first half would be insufferable. Keith Urban's performance
is a yawner, Placebo's vocals are obnoxious, and Robbie Williams foolishly
attempts to cover "We Will Rock You", with his theatrics toying the line
between distracting and outright silly.
The Who are able to turn the tide with
strong performances of "Who Are You" and "Won't Get Fooled Again". The
only real complaint is the exclusion of "Baba O'Riley". The next performance
is the absolute highlight of Live 8 - the reunion of Pink Floyd. Roger
Waters and David Gilmour perform as though they were never separated, with
the pinnacle occurring during the performance of "Wish You Were Here",
which was dedicated to Syd Barrett.
Although Pink Floyd would have put a great
end to the third disc of performances, Paul McCartney takes the stage to
cap off the night. Although Paul mainly plays predictable material, "Helter
Skelter" was thrown into the mix, adding adrenalin to the set. Even though
McCartney's voice never seems to age or tire, he turned the stage over
to the other musicians and allowed the crowd to help him finish the "nah
nah" ending of "Hey Jude".
Great performances: Pink Floyd,
Paul McCartney, The Who
Good performances: Neil Young
Poor performances: Rob Thomas,
Keith Urban, Placebo, Robbie Williams
The fourth disc suffers from the overall
length of the DVD package. The nighttime performances by The Who, Pink
Floyd, and Paul McCartney at the end of the third disc seemed like the
logical conclusion to this set of music. Although the fourth disc doesn't
showcase any terrible acts, it doesn't showcase anyone all that impressive,
either. One mediocre performance follows another, and you can't help but
wonder when the 10+ hours of music will come to an end.
As though there weren't enough performances
already, this disc contains a set of extras including a film by The Who
and a Pink Floyd rehearsal.
Great performances: Bjork
Good performances: Shakira, Audioslave,
Poor performances: Good Charlotte,
In conclusion, the goals of Live 8 are
admirable and impressive (both in regards to humanitarian progress and
wrangling so many "A list" artists). The length of the set is impressive,
yet overwhelming. Unless you are easily pleased, you'll give your remote
a workout searching for performances that are worth watching.
you missed Kevin's review of the special Africa Calling Live 8 at Eden
DVD click here!
DVD Info and Links
Live 8 DVD Boxset
and Purchase This DVD Online
articles for this artist
a friend about this review
Fan Speak Your turn,
post your comments and thoughts on this review and CD. But hey keep it
clean, we wouldn't want to have to wash your mouth out with Old Spice.